https://www.awm.gov.au/journal/j33/blackburn/
36} Both the Kanchanaburi and Changi sites illustrate how works of fiction (in these cases Pierre Boulle's Bridge over the River Kwai and James Clavell's King Rat) have shaped public perceptions to the extent that the re-creations of the past at the sites have reflected such fictions. The sites confirm David Lowenthal's point that when tourism authorities go about re-creating the past they try to represent what they think their visitors want to see. The STPB's work at revamping the Changi site demonstrates that both commodification and commemoration of the past can proceed together, though not without some difference of opinion. By involving male ex-POWs in the process of representing the POW experience, the Singapore tourism authorities won support from many ex-POWs, who saw the Changi Prison Museum as their own, one that embodied their own experiences. On the other hand, the creators of Changi Prison Museum appear to have decided not to include female civilian internees in the process of creating the museum because such images would conflict with the themes of King Rat. The result has been that while male ex-POWs have had little problem with the museum's main theme - a hard masculine world-former female internees have felt that the selection of material has excluded their experiences.
Kate Darian-Smith and Paula Hamilton eds, Memory and history in twentieth century Australia, Melbourne, Oxford University Press, 1994
The Burma-Thailand Railway: memory and history, Hank Nelson and Gavan McCormack eds, Sydney, Allen and Unwin, 1993
Notes
1. See Annette Hamilton, "Skeletons of empire: Australians and the Burma-Thailand Railway" in Kate Darian-Smith and Paula Hamilton eds, Memory and history in twentieth century Australia, Melbourne, Oxford University Press, 1994, pp. 92-112, and Kevin Blackburn, "Changi: A place of personal pilgrimages and collective histories", Australian historical studies 112, April 1999, pp. 153-73.
2. Hank Nelson, "Measuring the railway: from individual lives to national history", in
The Burma-Thailand Railway: memory and history, Hank Nelson and Gavan McCormack eds, Sydney, Allen and Unwin, 1993, pp. 22-3.
3. For recent critical studies of the conditions of the POW camps see Humphrey McQueen, Japan to the rescue, Melbourne, Heinemann, 1991, p. 265 and pp. 295-337; and Sibylla Jane Flower, "Captors and captives on the Burma-Thailand Railway", in Prisoners of war and their captors in Second World War, Bob Moore and Kent Fedorowich eds, Oxford, Berg, 1996, pp. 227-52. That the Japanese were not consistently brutal has been suggested by critically reading POW diaries, such as those of Stan Arneil, One man's war, Melbourne, Macmillan, 1982, and E.E. Dunlop,The war diaries of Weary Dunlop: Java and the Burma-Thailand Railway, 1942-1945, Melbourne, Penguin, 1990. can get books from PHX Public LIBR
4. David Lowenthal,
The past is a foreign country, Cambridge University Press, 1985, p. 347.
5. John Urry,
The tourist gaze: leisure and travel in contemporary societies, London, Sage Publications, 1990, and
Consuming places, London, Routledge, 1995.
6. Hamilton, "Skeletons of empire", p. 111.
7. Ronald Searle, To the Kwai and back: war drawings 1939-1945, London, Collins, 1986, p. 104.
8. Kevin Patience, "The death railway", After the battle 26, 1979, p. 12.
9. Hamilton, "Skeletons of empire", p. 106.
10. Patience, "The death railway", p. 14.
11. Hamilton, "Skeletons of empire", p. 106.
12.
Times, 1 December 1987.
13.
Straits times, 19 August 1957.
14. Interview with the Reverend Henry Khoo, Changi Prison Chaplain since 1967 and son of the first Singapore Prisons Chaplain, the Reverend Khoo Siaw Hua, 2 October 1997.
16.
Straits times, 7 September 1945.
17.
Straits times, 9 and 10 January 1948;
Malaya tribune, 9 January 1948.
18. Hank Nelson, "Travelling in memories: Australian prisoners of the Japanese, forty years after the fall of Singapore", Journal of the Australian War Memorial 3, 1983, p. 21; Straits times, 14 September 1995 and 24 April 1998.
19. Stan Arneil,
One man's war, p. 3.
20. Lionel De Rosario,
Nippon slaves, London, Janus, 1995, p. 45.
21. Hank Nelson,
P.O.W. Prisoners of war: Australians under Nippon, Sydney, Australian Broadcasting Commission, 1985, p. 34.
22. Russell Braddon,
The naked island (1952), London, Charnwood, 1982, p. 269.
23. Nelson,
Australians under Nippon, p. 68.
24. Rohan D. Rivett,
Behind bamboo (1946), Ringwood, Penguin, 1991, p. 158.
25. Bajintar Singh's Report, 3 March 1987, Project Activities: Changi Prison Chapel: A Plan to Redesign the Changi Prison Chapel, in Changi Prison Chapel & Museum, serial number 57, file reference number PD/PRJ/45/87, vol. 1 (MFL AJ024), STPB Records (National Archives of Singapore).
26. For example,
Papineau's guide to Singapore, Singapore, MPH Magazines, 1981, pp. 190-1.
27. Interviews with Pamelia Lee and Bajintar Singh, who worked on the STPB project team to create Changi Prison Museum, 23 September 1997.
28. Robertson E. Collins, Project Report, 8 March 1987: A Plan to Re-Design the Changi Prison Stop on the East Coast Tours, 57, PD/PRJ/45/87, vol. 1.
29. Changi Prison and East Coast Tour, 67, PD/PRJ/45/88, vol. 7.
30. Tourist Product Development Working Committee (TPDWC). For TPDWC Deliberation, Changi Prison Chapel Background, 21 March 1987, 57, PD/PRJ/45/87, vol. 1.
31. Pamelia Lee and Bajintar Singh, 23 September 1997.
32. Stanley Warren, Reel 2, Oral History Interviews, A000205/08 (Singapore National Archives).
33. James Clavell,
King Rat, London, Hodder and Stoughton, 1975.
34. Robertson E. Collins, Project Report, 8 March 1987: A Plan to Re-Design the Changi Prison Stop on the East Coast Tours, 57, PD/PRJ/45/87, vol. 1.
35. Ball Partnership, 15 January 1988, 60, PD/PRJ/45/87, vol. 4.
36. 103/88 20, 70, PD/PRJ/57/88, vol. 1; and Paper II Project: Changi Prison Chapel, 58, PD/PRJ/45/87, vol. 2.
37. Peggy Teo and Brenda S.A. Yeoh, "Remaking local heritage for tourism",
Annals of tourism research 24 (1), 1996, pp. 192-213.
38. For the actual chapel the tourist authorities wanted to re-create, see J.N. Lewis Bryan,
The churches of the captivity in Malaya, London, Society for the Promotion of Christian Knowledge, 1946, p. 65.
39. Robertson E. Collins, March 14 1987, Chiangi [sic] Chapel-Revised Plan; and Paper II Project: Changi Prison Chapel, 58, PD/PRJ/45/87, vol. 2; and For Managerial Approval, Battle of Singapore Project, Management Paper 139/37, 27 May 1987, 57, PD/PRJ/45/87, vol. 1.
40. See the August 1991 and June 1994 issues of
Barbed wire and bamboo, an Australian ex-POWs' magazine, for examples of the reaction of ex-POWs to the increased commercialisation of Kanchanaburi.
41. Desmond Battery, South Australia, to Mr Quek Shi Lai, Director of Prisons, 7 September 1987, 57, PD/PRJ/45/87, vol. 1.
42. Memorandum of Meeting 25 July 1987, and 29 August 1987, 57, PD/PRJ/45/87, vol. 1.
43.
Straits times, 9 September 1987; and Second World War Chapel and Museum: Changi Prison, press release, 8 September 1987, 57, PD/PRJ/45/87, vol. 1.
44. R.D. Evans, Cleveleys, Lancashire, 9 January 1988, 65, PD/PRJ/45/88, vol. 5.
45.
Sunday times (Singapore), 24 April 1988.
46. Ken Joyce to Roney Tan, Director STPB, Sydney, 12 May 1988, 65, PD/PRJ/45/88, vol. 5.
47. H.K. Mawby to Pamelia Lee, 8 August 1988, 66, PD/PRJ/45/88, vol. 6.
48. Tim Bowden,
Changi photographer: George Aspinall's record of captivity, Sydney, Allen and Unwin, 1984.
49. George Aspinall to Bajintar Singh, 5 November 1988, 67, PD/PRJ/45/88, vol. 7.
50.
Guardian, 23 April 1988.
51. Harold Payne to Pamelia Lee, 3 May 1990, 67, PD/PRJ/45/88, vol. 7.
52. Bernice Archer, "A patchwork of internment",
History today 47 (7 ), July 1997, pp. 16-17.
53.
Straits times, 25 April 1989.
54. Heritage and Culture Awards: Changi Prison Chapel, 20 January 1989, 61, PD/PRJ/45/88, vol. 7.